Top-Rated Workers Compensation Insurance for August 2023
Top-Rated Workers Compensation Insurance for August 2023
in ,

Top-Rated Workers Compensation Insurance for August 2023

Safeguard Your Business with Essential Workers Compensation Insurance. The workplace is susceptible to errors and accidents, and even a single incident can lead to severe repercussions. Without adequate workers compensation insurance in place, your business could face legal liabilities that may prove costly, even jeopardizing its survival.

When it comes to protecting your small business and its employees, workers compensation insurance is of paramount importance. To assist you in making an informed decision, we thoroughly assessed 25 insurers to identify the optimal workers compensation insurance options.

Workers Compensation Insurance Ratings

Company AM Best Financial Strength Rating Forbes Advisor rating for workers comp insurance
The Hartford A+
CopperPoint A
Everest Insurance A+
Great American Insurance A+
Pinnacol Assurance A-
Texas Mutual A
Arch Capital A+
Zurich A+
AF Group A
Fairfax Financial A
Old Republic A+
Starr A
AmTrust Financial A-
Berkshire Hathaway A+
Markel A
Chubb A++
Berkley A+
Employers A-
Encova A-
Erie Insurance A+
Liberty Mutual A
Travelers A++

Understanding Workers Compensation Insurance

Workers compensation insurance is a vital component of business insurance that provides coverage for employees who suffer injuries or illnesses directly related to their job. This type of insurance ensures that medical expenses and a portion of lost wages are paid, relieving the business owner from bearing the financial burden.

Almost every state mandates employers to carry workers compensation insurance, with the specific coverage requirements varying based on the nature of the business and its location.

Coverage under Workers Compensation Insurance:

  1. Medical Expenses: Workers compensation insurance policies cover the costs of medical treatments for employees who experience work-related injuries or illnesses. This includes expenses such as doctor’s visits, emergency room care, surgeries, medications, and ongoing medical care.

It’s worth noting that coverage for medical expenses related to Covid-19 may be included, subject to state regulations and the nature of the occupation. The National Council on Compensation Insurance closely monitors legislative developments concerning Covid-19 coverage under workers compensation.

  1. Lost Wages: When an employee is unable to work due to a job-related injury or illness, workers compensation insurance typically provides partial wage replacement. This ensures that the affected individuals still receive income during their recovery period.
  2. Disability Benefits: In cases where an employee experiences a work-related injury or illness resulting in a disability, workers compensation insurance may offer full or partial disability benefits. These benefits assist employees in managing medical bills and supplementing their lost wages.

Workers compensation insurance serves as a crucial safety net, providing financial protection to both employees and employers in the event of workplace accidents or occupational illnesses.

Exclusions and Requirements of Workers Compensation Insurance

While workers compensation insurance provides crucial coverage for work-related injuries and illnesses, there are certain circumstances and events that are typically not covered. It’s important to be aware of these exclusions and understand the requirements associated with workers compensation insurance.

  1. Commute: Accidents that occur during the commute to or from work are generally not covered by workers compensation insurance.
  2. Alcohol or Drugs: Injuries sustained while an employee is under the influence of alcohol or illegal drugs are typically not covered by workers comp insurance.
  3. Intentional Injuries: Workers compensation policies exclude injuries that are intentionally caused.
  4. Recreation: Injuries that arise from recreational activities, even if they occur on the work premises, are usually excluded from coverage.
  5. Food Poisoning: If an employee experiences food poisoning during a lunch break from food they purchased or brought from home, it is typically not considered work-related and does not qualify for workers compensation coverage.

It’s important to note that workers compensation insurance policies may have additional exclusions, so it’s advisable to carefully review your specific policy.

Workers Compensation Insurance Requirements:

Workers compensation laws are governed by state statutes, and the specific requirements vary depending on the location of your business. It is essential to check the workers compensation insurance laws in your state to determine the mandated coverage limits.

If your business operates in multiple states, you must comply with the respective state statutes for workers compensation insurance.

Consequences of Not Having Workers Compensation Insurance:

Failure to carry the required workers compensation coverage can result in penalties and legal consequences as determined by the specific state laws. This may include fines, criminal charges, or even imprisonment.

Additionally, not having workers compensation insurance leaves businesses vulnerable to lawsuits. If an employee is injured or falls ill due to job-related factors and the employer lacks workers comp coverage, the employee may file a lawsuit to recover their medical expenses.

Cost of Workers Compensation Insurance:

On average, workers compensation insurance costs small business owners around $47 per month or $560 annually, according to Trusted Choice, an association of independent insurance agents. This average cost applies to medium-sized businesses with moderate levels of risk. Larger companies operating in high-risk industries such as construction typically pay higher premiums.

Factors Affecting Workers Compensation Insurance Premiums

The cost of your workers compensation insurance premium can be influenced by several factors, including:

  1. Location: The state in which your business operates plays a significant role in determining the workers comp coverage requirements. States with higher mandates generally result in higher insurance premiums.
  2. Type of Business: The nature of your industry impacts the cost of workers compensation insurance. More hazardous occupations, such as construction, tend to have higher premiums compared to less risky professions like building design.
  3. Claims History: Insurers assess your company’s past workers compensation claims to gauge the likelihood of future claims. A history of frequent claims or severe injuries may result in higher premiums.
  4. Payroll Size: The number of employees and the overall payroll of your business are factors considered in calculating workers comp premiums. Larger payrolls typically lead to higher insurance costs.

Tips for Obtaining the Best Workers Compensation Insurance:

To secure the best workers compensation insurance for your business, follow these steps:

  1. Familiarize Yourself with State Requirements: Each state has specific workers compensation insurance requirements, even for industries considered low-risk. Ensure your business complies with the workers comp laws of the states where you have employees.
  2. Determine Insurance Providers: Depending on your state, workers comp policies may be offered by private insurance companies, state-run agencies, or the state itself. Some states have monopolistic state funds where you must purchase insurance. Determine the appropriate source for obtaining workers comp insurance based on your location.
  3. Work with an Insurance Agent: If you can purchase workers compensation insurance from private insurers, collaborate with an insurance agent to compare quotes. Note that the quotes may be subject to adjustment after the insurers evaluate your specific business risks.
  4. Mitigate Risk to Lower Premiums: Prioritize workplace safety to potentially reduce workers comp premiums. Assigning a safety manager, conducting regular safety meetings, and ensuring compliance with building and equipment regulations may make you eligible for premium discounts.


In evaluating workers compensation insurance companies, we considered the following factors:

  • Level of Complaints (90% of the score): We assessed companies based on upheld complaints reported to state insurance departments nationwide and collected by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.
  • Financial Strength (10% of the score): We considered the financial strength ratings from AM Best, a trusted rating agency specializing in the insurance industry.
Most Affordable Auto Insurance Providers (August 2023)

Most Affordable Auto Insurance Providers (August 2023)

Top 5 Most Affordable Home Insurance Providers

Top 5 Most Affordable Home Insurance Providers